Animation vs. Live Action: Which Is Right for Your Brand?

If you’re planning your next marketing video, one of the biggest questions you’ll face is: Should it be animated or live action?

Both can be incredibly effective when used for the right purpose. The key is understanding how each format aligns with your goals, audience, and budget.

At Broken Pencil Studios, we’ve helped brands of all sizes make that choice strategically, so their videos not only look amazing but actually work.

‍

Let’s break down the strengths (and limits) of each format to help you decide what’s best for your brand.

1. Animation: Creative, Flexible, and Timeless

Animation lets you visualize anything you can imagine, without being limited by cameras, sets, or real-world logistics. From explaining abstract concepts to bringing characters and data to life, animation makes complex ideas simple, emotional, and memorable.

✅ Pros of Animation:

• Unlimited creativity: You can show the invisible: ideas, feelings, or systems through colour, motion, and storytelling.
  
  
• Simplifies complexity: Perfect for explaining products, services, or processes that are hard to show in real life.
  
  
• Consistent and on-brand: Animated visuals can match your brand’s colours, tone, and style exactly.
  
  
• Long shelf life: Animation doesn’t age quickly: no trends, actors, or settings to date your content.
  
  
• Ideal for global audiences: No language or cultural barriers; visual storytelling speaks universally.
  

⚠️ Considerations:

• Animation takes time and planning: it’s not something you can film in a day.
  
  
• If your brand relies heavily on real-world authenticity or emotion (like customer testimonials), live action might feel more personal.
  
  

Best for: explainer videos, product demos, brand storytelling, SaaS, education, healthcare, or tech.

‍

2. Live Action: Relatable, Human, and Authentic

Live action brings your brand to life through real people, real places, and genuine emotion. It’s ideal for building trust, showcasing your team, or connecting on a personal level.

Pros of Live Action:

• Authenticity: Seeing real faces and voices creates an instant human connection.
  
  
• Emotional storytelling: Great for capturing genuine reactions, interviews, and behind-the-scenes moments.
  
  
• Quick turnaround: With a small crew, live-action videos can sometimes be produced faster than animation.
  
  
• Tangible products: Perfect for showcasing physical goods, environments, or real-world services.
  
  

Considerations:

• Costs can rise quickly with actors, locations, lighting, and equipment.
  
  
• Updates are harder: if branding or messaging changes, you often have to re-shoot.
  
  
• Limited visual flexibility: harder to visualize abstract or large-scale ideas.
  
  

Best for: brand videos, testimonials, ads, social media content, and product showcases.

‍

3. The Best of Both Worlds: Hybrid Videos

Who says you have to choose one? Many of the most effective campaigns combine animation and live action for maximum impact.

You can start with live action to build authenticity, then layer animation to explain concepts or visualize data. The result? A dynamic, emotionally engaging video that tells your story from every angle.

At Broken Pencil Studios, we often blend motion graphics, live footage, and illustration into seamless narratives that feel fresh, human, and unforgettable.

‍

4. How to Decide What’s Right for You

Ask yourself these questions before deciding:

• What’s the main goal of this video: education, sales, awareness, or emotion?
  
  
• Who is my audience, and how do they prefer to consume content?
  
  
• What’s my budget and timeline?
  
  
• Do I need flexibility to update or localize the video later?
  
  

If your goal is clarity, scalability, and long-term value, animation often wins.

If your goal is connection, emotion, and real-world authenticity, live action may be the better choice.

And if you want both? That’s where Broken Pencil Studios comes in.

‍