BPS Blogs |
#5 -
January 27th, 2026

Animation vs Live Action Video (How to Choose for Your Business)

Profile picture of the author.
Candela Pierotti

Project & Development Manager

Who this is for

This article is for marketing teams, founders, and organizations deciding whether animation, live action, or a mixed-media approach is the best fit for their message.

One of our clients, Ubiquity, needed to explain Aigent, an AI tool that supports customer service agents in real time. You can't point a camera at software thinking. So we animated it, and told the story through one support agent who goes from overwhelmed to confident.

That's the whole decision in a nutshell. Pick the format that can actually show your message.

The short answer

Animation explains. Live action connects.

If people need to understand how something works, animation usually wins. If people need to trust a real person, place or product, live action usually wins. Plenty of the best videos use both.

Choose animation when…

  • You need to show something a camera can't. Software, data, the inside of a machine, a process that takes weeks. Animation can open it up and slow it down.
  • Your message will change. When a step or a price changes, we update that scene. No reshoot, no rebooking actors.
  • You need several languages. Swap the voiceover and on-screen text, and the same video works in French, Spanish or any other language you need.
  • You want a look that's all yours. Every colour, character and movement can match your brand exactly.

Good fits: explainer videos, software and product demos, training and onboarding, technical and industrial processes, healthcare and education.

Choose live action when…

  • Trust comes from real faces. Customer stories, your team, a founder speaking to camera.
  • Your product or place is the star. A physical product, a facility, a community.
  • Emotion needs to feel unscripted. Real reactions are hard to fake in any format.
  • The idea is simple and you need it fast. A short shoot with a small crew can turn around quickly.

Good fits: testimonials, brand stories, recruitment videos, event coverage, social content.

Side by side

  • What drives the cost: for animation, the length, 2D or 3D, and the number of characters and scenes. For live action, crew days, locations, people on camera and equipment.
  • Updating it later: animation means changing one scene. Live action often means a reshoot.
  • Other languages: animation swaps the voiceover and on-screen text. Live action needs subtitles or a new shoot.
  • Showing the invisible: easy in animation, hard in live action.
  • Showing real people: animation is stylized. Live action shows them as they are.

For a sense of scale, short animated explainers at Broken Pencil Studios start around $20,000.

Or use both

A hybrid video starts with real people for trust, then adds animation to explain what they're talking about. A plant manager talks to camera, and an animated overlay shows how the system behind her works. You get the human connection and the clear explanation in one video.

Four questions to decide

  1. What should viewers do or understand afterward? If it's "understand how this works," lean animation. If it's "trust us," lean live action.
  2. Can you film it? If the answer is no, or not easily, animation decides it for you.
  3. How long will this video need to last? If your message will change within a year or two, animation is cheaper to keep current.
  4. Who's watching, and where? Several languages or regions favour animation. A local audience that wants to see your real team favours live action.

Still split after answering? That usually means a hybrid is the right call.

‍

Need help making your brand easier to understand?

Broken Pencil Studios helps teams turn technical, strategic, educational, and emotional ideas into visual content that is easier to understand and remember.

Book a discovery call to explore how animation and visual storytelling can help your audience understand what matters faster.

‍

Let’s connect and talk about your ideas!